Would farm restaurants help save Oregon farms?
Full text, courtesy of The Bulletin
MONMOUTH — It was something like love — and a business plan — at first sight.
Eden Olsen is a sixth-generation farmer who married a chef and the dynamic duo dreamed of opening a restaurant on acreage owned by Olsen’s family.
But Lucky Crow Farm sits just outside the city limits and Oregon law typically doesn’t allow for restaurants on land zoned for exclusive farm use.
In June, after months of renovating a leased location, Olsen and her wife Lindsay Darling opened the Lucky Crow Farmstand & Eatery in downtown Monmouth.
The restaurant has been successful, allowing Olsen to dramatically increase production, but the married couple remain frustrated.
An on-farm restaurant would reduce transportation time and costs and owning rather than renting would save money long-term.
“I’m not trying to not farm, but these days it’s really hard to make a living just selling vegetables,” Olsen said.
“Times are changing and the ability for a small farm to survive is less possible without some creative solutions,” she added.
Some producers — feeling hammered by poor commodity prices and high costs of inputs, labor and regulations — hope the Oregon Legislature will ease rules on farm restaurants when it reconvenes this winter.
Previous efforts failed even as other aspects of agritourism were passed into law. Most recently, that includes farm stores, which will be able to offer expanded food service.
“Food service is one thing. A farm restaurant is another,” said Jim Johnson, an adviser for 1,000 Friends of Oregon, a nonprofit that advocates for land-use planning.
Johnson said farm restaurants would generate considerable traffic in the countryside, increasing conflicts where people complain about common ag practices or even the smell of animals.
Critics also believe allowing farm restaurants would further increase property values, pricing out producers, and result in the loss of farmland to development.
Johnson, who previously worked at the Oregon Department of Agriculture and the Oregon Department of Land Use Conservation and Development, said farming is cyclical and currently in a rough patch.
“You don’t sacrifice the future of agriculture in the long term for some short-term issues,” he said.
The most significant problems — and potential solutions — facing farms aren’t related to land use policy, Johnson added.
Gathering Together and asking later
John Eveland, owner of Gathering Together Farm outside Philomath, said there’s a simple reason he’s able to operate a farm restaurant.
He didn’t ask for permission.
The restaurant evolved out of a traditional farm lunch for workers.
In the early 2000s, the business obtained a permit to sell sandwiches and soups to the public.
Eventually, Gathering Together hired a trained chef and provided seating.
The farm became a foodie destination and chefs moved on to create more stars for the local dining scene such as the Dizzy Hen and Birdie’s Pizza.
Years after the restaurant opened, there was a complaint, but officials in Benton County were familiar with the business and its impacts.
“All the county boys were coming out here and eating. They didn’t want it to go away,” Eveland said.
He and his wife and business partner Sally Brewer were able to secure a conditional use permit.
“It goes away the moment the farming operation goes away,” Eveland said.
For the past three years, the restaurant has made money but the farm hasn’t.
The farm and its 33 acres are for sale and the restaurant makes it attractive, Eveland said.
He hopes Oregon law changes to allow farm restaurants.
About a decade ago, he and Brewer visited Italy, touring agritourismo olive groves and small farms with food and lodging.
“Y’know, it was just a delightful experience. We came back and said, ‘Why can’t we do this?’” Eveland said.
Oregon’s Senate Bill 100
Polk County Commissioner Jeremy Gordon said commercial activity on farmland has been debated across Oregon since Gov. Tom McCall signed Senate Bill 100 in 1973.
That law guides development and created Oregon’s system of land use regulations, which prohibits many uses on farm and forest acreage.
In the case of Lucky Crow, the law functioned exactly as envisioned more than 50 years ago.
In an email, Gordon strongly supported protecting agricultural land from development but added that regulations should also recognize producers need opportunities to diversify and keep their farms financially viable.
“Agritourism, UGB (urban growth boundary) flexibility, farm-to-table dining and direct-to-consumer sales can help accomplish that without undermining the purpose of our land use system,” Gordon wrote.
“Outright bans may not be where the middle ground is,” he added in an interview.
No exception for restaurants
Exceptions to Senate Bill 100 have been made at the state level for certain commercial activities, but nothing specific has been carved out for farm restaurants, said Audrey Comerford, an Oregon State University agritourism expert.
Such eateries typically need special event permits and can only operate a few times per year.
In general, agritourism activities must be incidental and subordinate to existing farm use and no new structures can be built.
Wine, cider and beer tasting rooms that serve food often are allowed on farmland due to lobbying from those industries.
Some farms have delved into alcohol to offer food, Comerford said.
She said in recent years she has received far more questions and requests for advice regarding agritourism.
“Often it’s multigenerational farm operations that have never sold directly to consumers,” she said.
County planners interpret state laws differently, which creates confusion. What’s permitted in one county might not be approved elsewhere.
Comerford said frustrated farmers and ranchers sometimes charge ahead with agritourism activities without getting approval first, but that tactic doesn’t always work out well.
Loss of ag acreage, higher farmland prices
Jennifer Euwer, a Columbia Gorge pear grower and Hood River County commissioner, worried about an overarching state laws on agritourism because local control allows communities to decide what’s best for them.
Euwer said people need to be clear-eyed about the consequences of tweaking regulations.
Oregon’s land use laws not only protect the countryside, but downtowns and neighborhoods by ensuring businesses are located within commercial districts, she added.
Euwer said allowing more commercial uses on farmland inflates real estate prices and makes it more difficult for farmers to afford farming.
“The minute you allow uses that return more per acre than farming does, the value of that land increases by the same amount, which renders it unaffordable for the person who actually wants to farm,” Euwer said.
Farmers are almost compelled to pursue these additional commercial activities, she said.
“Instead of making it easier for people to farm, we’re going to turn you into wedding venues and restaurants. I think we have this backwards,” she added.
At some point, the demand for agritourism also becomes saturated, Euwer said.
“People like the novelty of going out to a restaurant on the farm, but what happens when there’s 50 of them?” Euwer said.
Hentze Farm cooks up business
That sounds like paradise to Patrick Fay, director of hospitality for Hentze Farm outside Junction City.
One day, he’d like to see farm restaurants and breweries proliferate throughout Oregon as part of a holistic culinary movement, food and beverages amidst fields and orchards where they’re grown.
And he’s not alone. A recent OSU survey revealed residents are eager to visit farms and soak in the scenery while eating fresh food.
Hentze Farm, which is nearly 125 years old, draws customers in with the Cook Shack, a food trailer that opened in 2009.
“We have one of the highest-rated restaurants around parked on our lawn,” Fay said.
The Cook Shack is allowed in Lane County because it doesn’t have wait staff or inside seating. However, that means it only operates during warm weather.
Fay keeps prices low at the Cook Shack as part of a “Costco chicken philosophy.”
“If someone eats here, they go to the farmstand and buy something else,” he explained.
Fay married into the Hentze family and took over the Cook Shack in 2019.
For 20 years, he was a waiter in some of Seattle’s best restaurants. He loved to cook and picked up tips from renowned chefs.
“For me to do farm-to-table was a no-brainer,” he said.
Fay had rose-colored glasses about Oregon’s vibrant culinary scene but those were shattered by an unfriendly business climate.
He said it took two years and $100,000 to get approval for a single-keg brewery at Hentze Farm. The delays and expense have temporarily shelved the project.
Finding a balance
…
Original story at The Bulletin
More News news
- 'What I was wearing is what survived' - sisters lose everything as fire destroys home East Anglian Daily Times, 7 hours ago
- Madras vs Molalla Boys Basketball - Feb 26, 2027 Sports Illustrated, 8 hours ago
- Central Oregon Daily News at 6:00 p.m. (Replay) Central Oregon Daily, 8 hours ago
- Time for winter tires: Les Schwab preps drivers and OAS shuttles for snow KTVZ, 8 hours ago
- Bend Central Library earns highest global green building honor Central Oregon Daily, 10 hours ago
- Pet Pals: JillyBean the sweet puppy is one of six siblings looking for a forever home! KTVZ, 10 hours ago