Saturday, November 21 Live

Bend Hub

News, roads, weather and events for Bend and Central Oregon.

News News

Losing Deschutes County sheriff candidate once again sues his election opponent

Full text, courtesy of The Bulletin

The losing candidate for Deschutes County Sheriff in the November election, Lieutenant James McLaughlin, filed a federal lawsuit against Sheriff Ty Rupert and Deschutes County for allegedly violating his First Amendment rights and political retaliation.

In the 49-page complaint filed Oct. 21 — weeks before Election Day — McLaughlin alleges that Rupert weaponized the sheriff’s office by retaliating against him for running for sheriff.

McLaughlin isn’t the only deputy that Ty Rupert has targeted, says McLaughlin’s attorney, Randy Harvey. Harvey said that lawsuits will continue to dog the sheriff’s office for the foreseeable future.

He alleges that Rupert may also target deputies associated with McLaughlin’s campaign and deputies with ties to the internal investigation that Harvey says cost McLaughlin the sheriff’s position.

McLaughlin demands a jury trial to decide monetary damages associated with the alleged complaints.

McLaughlin, whose family medical leave expired Nov. 19, also wants his job back, along with the county and Rupert to formally acknowledge that they violated his First Amendment rights.

Jason Carr, the spokesperson for the sheriff’s office, directed all questions regarding McLaughlin to county legal counsel.

“Defendants will vigorously defend against and contest the allegations and claims in the lawsuit filed by Mr. McLaughlin,” David Doyle, Deschutes County Legal Counsel, said.

McLaughlin’s most recent complaint

The 49-page complaint alleges that Rupert urged McLaughlin to defer his candidacy to later elections and offered him any other position or authority in the office if he chose not to run.

In the complaint, McLaughlin told Rupert of his intent to run for sheriff during a dinner at Rupert’s house.

Rupert allegedly proposed that if McLaughlin did not run for the interim position, McLaughlin would receive Rupert’s support and assistance in becoming the next full-time sheriff.

From August to December 2025, Rupert allegedly offered McLaughlin any promotion, assignment, or authority he wanted if he abandoned his intention to run for sheriff. McLaughlin says he rejected Rupert’s proposals and announced on Jan. 26, 2026 his intent to run against him in the November election.

After the announcement, Rupert allegedly reduced McLaughlin’s authority, access, and supervisory role and proposed a schedule change that would affect his time available for off-duty campaigning.

The complaint also alleges that Rupert and the county tilted the election results by releasing accusations of McLaughlin’s misconduct and recommending his termination during the campaign.

Rupert asserted during the election that the investigation into McLaughlin was out of his hands, but McLaughlin’s complaint alleges that Rupert continued to have access to investigator Jim Band.

“Rupert remained informed and involved while the County presented Band as an independent fact finder,” the complaint alleges.

The county also publicly released an unfinished termination document to the press before it was ever served to McLaughlin.

McLaughlin asserts that these public records damaged his campaign and caused donors and endorsers to decline to associate with him.

“You can do 10 things with complete excellence, and do one thing, as I will attest, that is not excellent, and that you got to answer for. And what are you known for, right now … you’re known for being the guy that says ‘vindictive’ on a ring camera,” McLaughlin said in an election interview. “I’ve got 19 years of saving lives, putting cases together and caring, doing the right thing when nobody else is watching … That is (not), however, what public perception is.”

McLaughlin is now the third person who has sued the sheriff’s office or the county after loosing the sheriff’s race. Rupert secured 68.5% of the unofficial election tally while McLaughlin nabbed 30% of the vote.

The county and Rupert are expected to respond to the complaint within the next 60 to 90 days, according to Harvey. However, only 3% of federal lawsuits go to trial. If it does, the trial could start a year or two from now.

“Hopefully, by the time this case is over, they will put policies and practices in place so something like this never happens again,” Harvey said.

McLaughlin’s first tort claim notice

This isn’t the first time the county received a notice from McLaughlin asserting that the Deschutes County Sheriff’s Office retaliated against him and infringed on his First Amendment rights.

On April 25, 2024 McLaughlin spoke as a citizen at a van der Kamp campaign event about the command culture and decision-making at the sheriff’s office.

McLaughlin was then served with a notice of an internal affairs matter from Captain Paul Garrison on May 29, 2024, a week after the 2024 primary election.

When McLaughlin questioned Garrison’s timing, Garrison allegedly responded by saying that matters would be fine after “silly season,” referring to the ongoing sheriff’s election.

Then, in June 2024, McLaughlin submitted a tort claim notice to the county and the sheriff’s office asserting retaliation and infringement of his speech rights for campaigning for van der Kamp.

The claim was settled outside of court and McLaughlin did not seek monetary damages.

Former deputy Eric Kozowski and former captain William Bailey have also sued the sheriff’s office for wrongful termination or violation of First Amendment rights.

Kozowski ran against then-Sheriff Shane Nelson and was put on leave following an internal investigation and fired in 2018.

Shortly thereafter, Kozowski sued Nelson, claiming wrongful termination and retaliation and won over $1 million in damages in 2021. The county also paid $1.2 million in legal fees to fight the suit.

Harvey says Kozowski’s case and McLaughlin’s case are mirror images of each other. Harvey also represented former Sheriff Kent van der Kamp during his arbitration with the state’s Police Policy Committee.

Harvey claims that due to McLaughlin’s tort claim and the Kozowski case the county should have already learned their lesson about the patterns of corruption in the sheriff’s office.

Original story at The Bulletin

More News news

Search the site · Map · Report a correction