Saturday, November 21 Live

Bend Hub

News, roads, weather and events for Bend and Central Oregon.

News News

Audit: Deschutes County homelessness spending lacked oversight

Full text, courtesy of The Bulletin

Deschutes County has spent $25 million to combat homelessness over the past five years.

But commissioners — faced with a internal audit that noted their work did not fully report how staff time, funding and resources were all used to fight homelessness — came to differing conclusions about the money spent and the audit’s conclusions on Nov. 4.

Elizabeth Pape, the county’s internal auditor, set out to determine if the county used best practices to combat homelessness over the past five years in the only audit published this year, on Oct. 13.

Commissioner Patti Adair questioned the sheer amount of money spent over the past five years. Commissioner Tony DeBone felt the commissioners were not united, either with each other or the city or county, regarding homelessness outreach. Commissioner Phil Chang was disappointed, he said, that the audit did not include more of the impact of the work done across the county, and said mental health supports likely saved money in the long run.

Though the commission disagrees on a homeless framework now, in January the new five-member liberal commission will take their seats and may find it easier to come to consensus. Incoming commissioner Rick Russell has experience with safe parking programs in Redmond, and Mountain View Community Development, which he leads, received county funding.

Adair mentioned that the number of people who are homeless in the region is dropping, but wondered at the return on investment after the county has spent millions of dollars on outreach.

The county’s homeless outreach work ranged from case management and mental health support at the temporary “safe stay” area north of Bend to progress on a number of income-restricted housing developments throughout the county. Funding went to housing and outreach programs like Bend-Redmond Habitat for Humanity, NeighborImpact and the St. Vincent de Paul Society. The county also helped open a delayed managed camp in Redmond that has case management on site a few hours a day, according to the Redmond Spokesman.

The managed camp and other programs will continue to need operational funding, and the new commissioners will have hard choices ahead of them to decide what merits funding from a shrinking supply.

No single defined program

The internal audit on the county’s homelessness practices noted that though the county has spent $25 million on homeless outreach between 2021 and 2026, the county hasn’t managed procedures well and the commissioners had little information “to oversee spending, risks and results,” said the report.

The county does not have a single defined program to address homelessness, and several departments carried out homeless outreach-related work, said the report. County oversight, it claims, did not fully grasp what was done.

The audit recommended the county further document and report its actions regarding homeless outreach, housing and the county’s role throughout the region. The report asked for a county policy regarding outgoing grants to keep track of selection, agreement terms and performance measures, and recommended the county maintain an inventory of existing county resources and service capacity.

County administrators Nick LeLack, Whitney Hale and Erik Kropp said they continue to be concerned that the audit doesn’t take all the context into account or “consider the county’s operational and regional circumstances,” said their response. The administration does not intend to implement any of its recommendations, they wrote.

Scott Cooper, executive director of NeighborImpact, which received nearly a million dollars from the county for Covid-stimulus funding and mortgage and rental assistance, said county staff did the best they could during a time when everyone was scared and working from home. The commission’s lack of plan didn’t help.

“It was economic stimulus, no one was measuring performance,” he said. “The audit was not inaccurate but lacked context. I think the most gifted manager would have struggled (during Covid).”

NeighborImpact used the funding to organize and run an emergency shelter out of a rented motel in Bend for those living homeless who had Covid. It was an essential public health need that required operational support, Cooper said. The shelter was open for a year and a half, and “the day we closed that motel was one of the happiest of my life,” he said. The effort was supported by all three counties.

The audit came out at an “awkward moment,” said DeBone.

“(The internal audit process) started off in a good place, we want to do good things. We want to look for fraud, waste and abuse,” said DeBone of the 2002 creation of the internal audit.

He felt that the board is split three ways and is not working effectively with the rest of the county and the city.

The audit’s recommendations focused on transparency and oversight rather than fraud, but noted that the county should create a policy for outgoing grants that includes payment expectations.

“We’ve spent millions and millions of dollars on the homeless,” said Adair. “The governor was actually citing our region because our numbers went down 19%. But when you look at how many millions we’ve spent, what is our return on our investment?…You brought up NorthPoint (Vista) in Redmond. That still isn’t open, and we allocated that land years ago for the city and affordable housing.”

Adair said she wanted the temporary safe stay area north of Bend to be smaller than it was so it could more easily be accessed by outreach teams.

Chang said one of his biggest concerns with the audit were comparisons with other counties. He felt that because there was no agreement between commissioners, there couldn’t be a well-organized program.

“From my perspective, there is no county that is doing a good job at this in Oregon that we should be holding ourselves up against,” he said. “I am disappointed that this audit focused on how homeless response efforts were organized rather than what the impact and outcomes of all that work and investment were.”

Chang was surprised by some of the audit’s points, including that there was nothing reported for the objective to expand opportunities for residential development on county-owned properties. He noted several projects across the county that fell under that objective, including College View Apartments in Bend and La Pine’s Wickiup Station Apartments. Property management has reported on these efforts to the board, he said, which has tracked those projects.

County staff expenditures was $10.6 million, much of which went into behavioral health supports for people living on China Hat Road or in the Junipers east of Redmond, said Chang. The county also awarded $14.4 million to local homeless outreach providers.

“If we spent a couple million dollars on the host team (providing behavioral health supports) over the past five years, we have avoided millions and millions of dollars of costs at our emergency room, among law enforcement officers on patrol, at our jail, from fire and rescue units around our community,” said Chang. “That is one of the most compelling reasons to make these kinds of investments.”

Original story at The Bulletin

Also reported by

More News news

Search the site · Map · Report a correction